124 Best Dishes

We scoured the city for the top offerings on Chicago’s world-class restaurant scene. From appetizer through dessert, from über haute pineapple rum soup to down-home juicy fried chicken, here’s your road map to the 124 yummiest dishes around.

(page 3 of 9)

Pheasant hot dog from Hot Doug’s


Bistro Monet
There are people who love Bistro Monet—we’ve overheard them lavishing praise on the chef on their way out the door. We’re not so swept away, though there’s no denying the appeal of his short rib ravioli. Dressed in mushroom cream sauce with a splash of Madeira and topped with a barely there layer of melted Gruyère cheese, the al dente pasta hides ultratender strands of meat. It’s retro Franco-Italian, in the best possible way. 462 Park Blvd., Glen Ellyn; 630-469-4002 [$10.50] 

Chef de cuisine Michael Sheerin’s thick slab of sweetbreads is rendered perfectly browned and crisp outside, moist and tender inside. He serves a giant lobe with ribbons of frizzled carrots (from Green Acres Farm), preserved lemon-hazelnut yogurt, candied caraway, and soft red beets. A wonderful way to get your DCA: daily cholesterol allotment. 619 W. Randolph St.; 312-715-0708 [$13] 

Blu Coral
We’re tired of overly precious maki inventions that look more like anime fantasies than food. This one manages to be both gorgeous and mouthwatering, a circle of salmon and salmon roe over snow crab meat with sweet miso sauce that resembles an edible red twilight over the Pacific. 6320 S. Rte. 53, Woodridge; 630-719-8808 [$13] 

Homemade wasabi mustard sauce tops one veal cheek roulade; red wine/horseradish mustard jazzes the other. Once you dig in, the sauces seep into the impossibly tender meat, mix splendidly with the purée of runner beans, and serve as a warm dressing for the grilled treviso (radicchio) on the plate. It’s hard to decide which morsel to save for last. 1729 N. Halsted St.; 312-337-6070 [$24]

Bourgeois Pig Café
This popular sandwich at Lincoln Park’s perennial coffeehouse doesn’t conjure up bullfights and fiestas, but it’s a culinary work of genius in its own right. Smoked turkey, melted Swiss cheese, hummus, and red onion are grilled to perfection on crusty, thick sun-dried tomato bread. It’s somehow impossible to replicate at home—trust us; we’ve tried. 738 W. Fullerton Ave.; 773-883-5282 [$8]

Cafe Matou
Sweet and silky mussels get an accent of rustic spice after they’re cooked in pinot noir, lending a rounder and deeper flavor than what you get with more commonly used white wines. Star anise contributes a hauntingly exotic herbal tone. This is simple bistro fare transformed into a serious dish. 1846 N. Milwaukee Ave.; 773-384-8911 [$10.25] 

Cafe Spiaggia
Tossed with parsley, garlic, lemon, and roasted bread crumbs, the tender, earthy sections of slow-roasted small artichoke hearts come just slightly browned and totally enjoyable. It’s a classic Italian dish executed perfectly. 980 N. Michigan Ave.; 312-280-2750 [$12] 

There are plenty of reasons to visit Gilbert Langlois’s genteel and Southern-ish boîte in Lincoln Square. Just make sure someone at the table orders the fried chicken, cracklin’ good, unbelievably juicy on the inside, and served with blessedly unreinterpreted sides—buttermilk mashed potatoes, collards, and a creamy white gravy—that hit the nail square on the head. 4343 N. Lincoln Ave.; 773-477-7144 [$19]

Charlie Trotter’s
Twenty years in, Charlie’s vegetable tasting menu still amazes. Here’s a perfect example, which you’d be lucky to find on hand: Grilled red plum halves star with a supporting cast of poached elephant garlic, amaranth, Swiss chard, and Thai long pepper-infused merlot. The dish brilliantly breaks all expectations about fruits and vegetables, grains and spices, and does so deliciously. 816 W. Armitage Ave.; 773-248-6228 [$130 vegetable dégustation] 

Chef’s Station
Set on a bed of sweet peas with corn ragoût and grilled scallions, two juicy, lightly browned fillets are delicately flavored under their restrained cloak of sweet paprika beurre blanc. A scattering of crisp fried spinach leaves completes the picture. 935 Davis St., Evanston; 847-570-9821 [$28] 

Often called the “foie gras of the sea,” monkfish liver displays fatty richness similar to that of its terrestrial counterpart. Chiyo presents it as ann-kimo, poached in Cognac and served in a martini glass with pickle garnish—smooth and decadent, yet not at all fishy. 3800 W. Lawrence Ave.; 773-267-1555 [$8]

Coco Pazzo
Chicago is full of places palming off mushy, soupy rice casseroles under the name of risotto. But this is the real deal: A fine, firm, nutty texture showcases the flavor of earthy fresh porcini accented with Parmigiano-Reggiano. 300 W. Hubbard St.; 312-836-0900 [$24] 

Crofton on Wells
Amid her meaty American menu, Suzy Crofton always includes nice, creative vegetarian selections. We’re die-hard carnivores, but whenever we see the delightful quinoa and corn johnnycakes, the size and shape of silver-dollar pancakes, with chanterelles, sweet corn emulsion, and poblano oil, we go vege for the evening. 535 N. Wells St.; 312-755-1790 [$12]

Curry Hut
Nepalese cooking isn’t exactly the in cuisine around town, but Curry Hut’s Indian menu includes authentic dishes from this remote Himalayan country. Delectable mo mo dumplings of spiced minced chicken reflect a Chinese influence via Tibet, but the accompanying mustardlike Nepali achar sauce delivers a kick more like Indian chutney. 410 Sheridan Rd., Highwood; 847-432-2889 [$8] 

Custom House
Custom House braises the boneless leg and thigh of a Swan Creek Farms rabbit in root vegetables with pearl onions and serves them in a cast-iron pot with mustard spätzle. Brilliant. Adding to the contrasting textures and tastes is a side of boneless saddle of rabbit wrapped in thinly sliced house-made bacon. 500 S. Dearborn St.; 312-523-0200 [$26]

D & J Bistro
You might be tempted to order a bistro classic such as profiteroles or crème brûlée, but then you’d be missing out on one of D & J’s tastiest desserts. Passion fruit mousse is rolled with fresh strawberries in rice paper and topped with refreshing mango coulis and a raspberry drizzle. Completely unexpected and disarmingly pretty, this hits the spot. 466 S. Rand Rd., Lake Zurich; 847-438-8001 [$6.50]


Plate from Willow




7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

What's with the total lack of South Side restaurants? Except for a few places in Chinatown, you don't have a single dish from the South Side...

7 years ago
Posted by Jon L

Re: South Side restaurants...

It's always been that way, in magazines and the newspaper. Apparently there is no place worth eating on the South Side.

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

Jeez, your best appetizer is a part of an otherwise overwhelmingly Americanized 12-course meal. You can get a more authentic "One-Bite Salad" at Spoon Thai on Western for, IIRC, $6.00. Oh, and it feeds four people as part of a multi-course meal that you'd have trouble spending $85.00 on. Oh, and that $85.00 is for four.

Ask for the translated Thai menu and you'll be transported to Thailand.

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

There is one dish from Tin Fish in Tinley Park

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

Try the scallops at West Town Tavern!

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

the brisket sandwich at Cooper's - smoky, succulent, delicious...& don't forget about those fries..

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

Laura you so pretty!!


7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

You are so pretty...forgot the "are"

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

For those of us foodies on the South Side I agree we were not represented at all. Yes we do have some wonderful restaurants but they are few and far between. Are people not willing to make the trek out south ? Yes we do need MORE restaurants to take advantage of the reasonable rents and to give the communities a chance to experience good quality food.

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

can someone please actually recommend some south side restaurants (instead of just griping about lack of representation)?

7 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

You must try LeRoy Brown's! It's truely authentic ethnic cuisine. Best in town.

6 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

should we go throught the list of South Side city & suburban locations.

Negro League Cafe
Ragin Cajun
Dixie Kitchen
Chi Tung
The Pit

Or should I continue

6 years ago
Posted by Anonymous

The southside has no representation because if its not fried its not on the southside. And The Pit should never be counted as good food unless you have never tasted real BBQ

4 years ago
Posted by amelias chicago

Have you try Amelia's at 4559 S. Halsted will be nice to see one of their dishes in the made just for north side magazine.

4 years ago
Posted by south-side-mike

Chuck's Southern Comfort Café
6501 W 79th St.
Burbank, IL 60459
Owner Chuck Pine used to work for Baylis at Fontera Grill.
Unique restaurant with combo of BBQ, Cajun, Mexican and American foods...
Once you go there… you will be back

Submit your comment