The Bagelers Coffeehouse Zeroes in on Lincoln Park

The couple behind the new bagel café developed their own recipe for a “Chicago-style” dough.

Bagels from The Bagelers Coffeehouse   Photo courtesy Chelsey Torres

Several years ago, Jotam Torres, a manager at Zaleski & Horvath MarketCafe in Kenwood, heard his bosses talking about how they couldn’t find a good bagel on the South Side. Torres’s wife, Chelsey, had attended the French Pastry School after getting laid off as a credit analyst. Jotam told the bagel-bereft Z & H owners his wife’s grandma makes amazing bagels.

“There was no recipe, and she had never made a bagel in her life,” Jotam says. They started learning how to make bagels that very night. Not long afterward, they brought in a half-dozen bagels to Z & H, and they sold. Thus began a life lived in bagels.

Breakfast-forwarding several years, the Torreses have just opened The Bagelers Coffeehouse (2461 N. Lincoln Ave., 872-802-0347). They supply the café from their own wholesale business in Griffith, Indiana, where the bagels and croissants—another specialty—proof for days. The wholesale business delivers about 3,500 bagels and 2,100 croissants a week to Goddess & Grocer, the Langham Hotel, Metropolis Coffee Company, Ipsento, and other locations.

The bagels, which the Torreses call Chicago-style, boil for a few minutes to set the crust, as New York–style bagels do. The Bagelers’ bagel dough also contains the add-ons normally found only on top, such as the garlic, onion, and seeds in an everything bagel.

Impressive how these bagels have risen in just a few short years. Given their genesis from a fib—and the slang usage of “bagel” to mean “zero”—they have really made something out of nothing.



Comments to this blog are moderated. We review them in an effort to remove foul language, commercial messages, and irrelevancies.

Submit your comment