It’s like a ’70s basement house party, but better: wood paneling, taxidermied fish, and fruity drinks—such as a tequila punch spruced up with Luxardo bitters and sage—that go down way too easy.

Who’s there:Thalia Hall concertgoers and postdinner barhoppers
What to order:Space Juice for Jered ($8 a glass, $59 a bowl): tequila, grapefruit, lime, Luxardo bitters, black pepper, sparkling wine, sage